Vicky Sargent

Blog Watch No.3: Digital divide; universal credit

By: Vicky Sargent, Director at Boilerhouse
Published: Tuesday, September 18, 2012 - 11:10 GMT Jump to Comments

My week began at Digital Futures 12, where I was speaking about Channel Shift – the challenge of getting people to use public services online.

Digital Futures 12, organized by Shropshire County Council has been well blogged about by Jon King (self-styled 'militant optimist' working in a UK local authority) as well as many others listed on the event website.

Much of the debate at Digital Futures was about the ‘digital divide’ and whether its existence is a reason to slow up the government-sponsored drive to ‘digital by default’ with its aim of delivering of 80% of all public services online.

Anyone who follows the blog of Helen Milner, Chief Executive of UK Online Centres, will know that her response to the digital divide is to try to close it, by providing appropriate support to get everyone online. “The internet”, she wrote in her blog on 10 September, “can really open up lives, so as many people as possible should be encouraged to use it - and use it more.”

“Building online services that people need to use” she was talking about Universal Credit, of which more later, “is a great way of introducing people to the internet, and helping them to gain skills that will positively impact on other areas of their lives.” In the 21st century, she goes on to say, having digital skills is as essential as reading and numeracy.

Patrick Barwise, emeritus professor at London Business School and chairman of Which? took a similar stance at a UK Online Centres/LSE symposium this week, where he repeated points from his LSE blog earlier this year. A few basic online applications like email, the web and online shopping, he said, could transform the lives of the 8 million or so people in the UK who are not online. This would save them time and money, reduce their isolation, re-engage them in wider society and the economy – and enable them to use online public services. So getting people online is a powerful and cost-effective way of reducing inequality.

That’s the moral case, but the financial one is equally strong says Barwise, arguing that government funding for the work of UK Online Centres and others trying to bridge the digital divide is simply not enough.

The civil servant - a senior policy adviser specialising in Digital Policy - who writes the Bish Bash Blog (views his own, obviously) agrees that successive governments have not been as effective in tackling digital exclusion as they might have been.

Governments have tended to rely on others to tackle digital exclusion, he says, offering small pots of funding support rather than intervening directly. Fine, maybe, when channel choice was available, but if people are required to use an online service, can the government remain non-interventional, he asks.

The digital divide is just one of many concerns being raised about Universal Credit, the Government’s scheme to simplify the benefits system and provide better incentives for welfare claimants to re-enter the jobs market.

Writing in the Guardian’s housing network blog, Jon Land, editor of 24housing magazine, echoed widespread concerns about the impact of Universal Credit that had been raised at the weekend in BBC reports, and followed up with a House of Commons Opposition Day debate on the topic last Tuesday. ‘Safely shrouded from the real world, Iain Duncan Smith and Lord David Freud continue to work on universal credit,’ he said, people were becoming increasingly aware that universal credit is ‘a car-crash waiting to happen.’

Charity for the homeless St Mungos was worried specifically about direct payments – the arrangement under Universal Credit whereby everyone will get money for their rent paid directly to them, rather than straight to the landlord.

Writing in the St Mungo’s blog, Tanya English points out that some claimants will inevitably see a cash windfall as a temptation to binge drink, or leaping to the demands of the drug dealer before those of the landlord. So, without direct payments, some landlords could be left with no other choice but to evict their tenants.

Even more landlords will take the safe option, and avoid housing someone with problems in the first place. With homelessness continuing to rise, she argues, surely this is not a risk worth taking?

But there is support for Universal Credit from some perhaps unexpected quarters, including the Joseph Rowntree foundation blog, where public affairs manager Gordon Hector countered Frank Field’s broadside against UC published in the Guardian earlier in the week.

Hector says that key principles behind UC - making many benefits into one, and making work pay – are good. The key question therefore becomes whether universal credit will actually achieve these principles, justifying its  £2bn price tag.

Hector argues that JRF research suggests UC will mean 900,000 or so people would no longer be in relative poverty. Its overall distributional effect, he says, is pro-poor, with the highest gain in disposable income being seen in the bottom income decile. UC also improves on current disincentives for working (even if it does not remove them).

Apart from whether Universal Credit will deliver the intended benefits (no pun intended), there are, inevitably, other questions about whether the IT systems behind it will work.

A key issue that the IT team needs to resolve for an ‘online only’ service, as UC is intended to be, is how to establish that claimants are who they say they are. Asserting an identity on the Internet currently varies from online service to online service. At the lowest level, it may be an email address and at the highest level it can include postal address, credit card number, date of birth and some other details.

To tackle identity problem for Universal Credit, says Alan Mather in his blogpost Making An Identity Market, the DWP is planning to create a market of competing identity providers able to provide ‘portable online identities’. This will mean that in future, being trusted by your bank to do business online could mean that you will also trusted to do the same by government services.

The government wants to change that.  DWP are, as Cabinet Office say, "the first cab off the rank" but they will be followed by others (HMRC are discussing their approach with the market and will perhaps issue a procurement later this year or early next year).

The problem is, it's not yet clear how this is going to work, and consequently how attractive a proposition entering the identity market will be to intended suppliers. ‘There is plenty that could still go wrong’ ends the piece, concluding: ‘Fingers crossed it doesn't, this is important stuff.’

Share this article

Your comment

As you haven't logged in yet please either supply your name and email or login with your account.

By posting your comment, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Comments

Town Hall
Open conversations are crucial so that service providers can understand a council's wider objectives, propose innovative ways to meet them and save taxpayer's money, writes public services expert Jim Bligh.
Social equality will drive forward a sustainable ecological community, writes environmental scientist Paul Francis Bright as he describes his vision of a sustainable world.
After weeks of scrapping over responsibility for the out of hours care crisis, NHS England today announced a review to be led by NHS medical director Sir Bruce Keogh.
The environmental third sector is growing but we should be concerned about its capacity to shape a sustainable future, writes Professor Graham Smith of the Third Sector Research Centre.
The UK Government wants to change the rules on GM crops based on political and commercial interest as Australia beefs up the scientific checks and balances on GM production.
Mobile phone apps have triggered the beginning of a high street rebirth, writes digital marketing expert, Darren Kingman, from www.2save.co.uk.
'The future of making is changing again, and cities and citizens will lead the way', says an expert of Human-Future interaction.
Bee numbers have seen dramatic decline all over the world and in the UK bee populations have fallen by 30% since 2007, writes British Labour MEP Glenis Willmott.

View features archive >

Latest

Lesley Dixon, the chief executive of Person Shaped Support (PSS), argues that people should be at the heart of the health sector.
Britain's summers are riddled with showers and covered in cloud - and today the UK's meteorologists have met to discuss whether these weather patterns are linked to global warming.
The huge sums of money being invested in High Speed 2 (HS2) could be better spent on smaller, more robust schemes such as improving the capacity and speed of regional train lines, an influential thinktank has argued in a report published today.

View news archive >

Latest Press Releases

The prize, announced by the Department of Health, will recognise innovative ways of integrating care for people with dementia.
The Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE) has announced an additional £3.1 million programme to encourage more people to study languages at university.
Max3000 to provide the public sector with monitoring & management of cloud services via Giii G-Cloud Framework

View press release archive >